Roth conversions

When does a Roth conversion actually pay off?

The first time I sat down to decide whether to convert part of my own pre-tax savings to Roth, I did what most people do: opened a spreadsheet, typed in a few guesses, and stared at the answer without trusting it.

The question sounds simple: is it worth paying tax now to avoid tax later?. But the answer hides inside two numbers most of us can only guess at: your tax rate today, and your tax rate years from now when you'd actually withdraw the money. I built a free calculator to settle it for my own numbers. But before you use it, here's the one rule that decides nearly every case.

Quick answer. A Roth conversion pays off when your tax rate at withdrawal ends up higher than your tax rate today. If the rate is the same both years, it's roughly a wash. The amount you convert, the growth rate, and the years don't change that verdict; they only scale how much is at stake. One real wrinkle: paying the conversion tax from savings on the side, instead of withholding it from the conversion, adds a real edge of its own: the worked example and free calculator below show exactly how much.

The only rule that matters

A Roth conversion pays off when your tax rate at withdrawal is higher than your tax rate today. That's it. Everything else (growth rate, how much you convert, how many years it has) is detail.

Think of $100,000 sitting in a traditional IRA. You have two choices:

If your rate is the same both years, the two choices tie: the math washes out exactly (try it in the calculator: set both rates to 24% and watch the difference go to zero). If your future rate is higher, converting wins. If today's rate is higher, converting loses. Growth rate and time don't change that verdict: they just scale how much is at stake either way.

Watch the calculator in use

A short video tutorial of the free calculator, with three examples, if you'd rather watch than read.

The video loads from YouTube only when you press play. Watch on YouTube

A worked example with real numbers

Say you're 60, you won't touch the money until 75, you convert $100,000, and you assume 7% annual growth. Over 15 years at 7%, that $100,000 becomes about $275,903 either way: the only question is who gets taxed on it, and when.

Case 1: 22% now, 24% later

The classic low-income gap-years scenario: a lower bracket now, but RMDs push you higher later.

Case 1: 22% now, 24% later
Convert: pay 22% now, remaining $78,000 grows to$215,204
Don't convert: $275,903 grows, then pay 24% at withdrawal, keep$209,686
Converting saves you$5,518

Low-income years can pay off a second way. For 2027 contributions, the federal Saver's Match deposits up to $1,000 into your retirement account, a 50% match on your first $2,000 saved, if you have earned income. The catch is the income limit: the match ends at $71,000 for joint filers ($35,500 single), and conversion income counts toward it, so the $100,000 conversion above would put you well over. Decide which job the low-income year does. How the Saver's Match works (the rules are still proposed, not final).

Case 2: 24% now, 22% later

Same household, rates flipped: still working at a high income now, a quieter retirement later.

Case 2: 24% now, 22% later
Convert: pay 24% now, keep$209,686
Don't convert: grows, then pay 22% at withdrawal, keep$215,204
Converting costs you$5,518

Notice the symmetry: the same $100,000, the same 15 years, the same 7% growth, and the verdict flips entirely on which rate is higher. That's the whole game, as long as the tax bill comes out of the conversion itself.

Does it matter how you pay the tax bill?

A little: enough to flip a verdict, not just move it. Both examples above assumed the tax gets withheld from the conversion, so only the after-tax amount ever lands in the Roth. Pay that bill from savings outside the IRA instead (money that's already been taxed once) and the full converted amount grows tax-free. That sounds like it should just win by whatever the tax bill would've grown to, but a fair comparison has to charge for what that outside money gives up by being spent early.

Here's the part that isn't obvious: unlike the IRA, that outside money's principal is never taxed again either way; only its own future growth would be, and only if you'd left it invested. Spending money that was never fully exposed to tax in the first place, to eliminate tax on money that otherwise would be, is a genuinely good trade. Run the same two households through the calculator with "outside savings" selected instead of the default, and here's what changes:

Does it matter how you pay the tax bill?
Pay from the conversion itselfPay from outside savings
Case 1: 22% now, 24% laterSaves $5,518Saves $14,806
Case 2: 24% now, 22% laterCosts $5,518Saves $3,770

Look at Case 2: the rate spread alone said don't convert. Paying from outside savings flips it to a win, not a rounding artifact, a real structural edge, because the money funding the tax bill was never going to be fully taxed to begin with. The calculator's "Does it matter how you pay the conversion tax?" section has the full derivation and formula, plus a toggle so you can check both ways against your own numbers.

What do other rate gaps look like?

The same $100,000, 15 years and 7% growth, with other pairs of flat rates. A positive number means converting comes out ahead:

What do other rate gaps look like?
Tax rate now → at withdrawalTax due nowTax paid from the conversionTax paid from outside savings
12% → 22%$12,000+$27,590+$32,234
22% → 22%$22,000$0+$8,514
24% → 32%$24,000+$22,072+$35,582
32% → 24%$32,000−$22,072−$8,563
37% → 24%$37,000−$35,867−$20,247

The pattern holds in every row: the bigger the gap in favor of converting, the bigger the win, and paying the tax from outside savings helps in every case. The calculator page has the full table.

The honest part

Most Roth conversion calculators are built to sell you on converting. They bury the assumptions, hide the math, and always seem to land on "yes, convert!"

I built ours the other way. The first thing I wanted it to do was talk you out of a bad conversion. Run the numbers above (24% now, 22% later) and it tells you plainly: converting would cost you an estimated $5,518. No signup, no email wall, no "talk to an advisor" gate. Just the number.

Run your own numbers. Enter your rates, growth assumption, and timeline. See the verdict in seconds, free, no signup.

Try the free Roth conversion calculator

What does the simple version miss?

The calculator is deliberately simple: seven inputs, one verdict. Real life has more traps:

None of those fit in a seven-input calculator. They're exactly what Runway's full planner models: year by year, against your real brackets, IRMAA tiers, and RMD schedule, not a single flat snapshot.

But start with the simple question. If the simple math says don't convert, the complicated math rarely disagrees. And if it says convert, well, now you know it's worth running the full plan.

Frequently asked questions

Is the tax on a Roth conversion due in the year I convert?

Yes. The IRS says converted amounts are "normally included in income on your return for the year that you converted them" (Publication 590-A). The converted amount is added to that year's income and taxed at your ordinary rates, so a large conversion can push you into a higher bracket.

Is there an income limit on Roth conversions?

No. The IRS says: "Regardless of the amount of your adjusted gross income, you may be able to convert amounts from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA" (Topic no. 309). The exception is money you must take as a required minimum distribution for the year, which can't be converted.

Can I undo a Roth conversion?

Not any more. The IRS says "conversions after 2017 from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA may not be recharacterized" (Topic no. 309). Once you convert, the tax for that year is owed, so test the numbers before you convert.

How long must converted money stay in the Roth?

Each conversion has its own five-year clock: "A separate 5-year period applies to each conversion and rollover" (Publication 590-B). Taking out the taxable part of a conversion inside that period can trigger the 10% additional tax unless an exception applies, and reaching age 59½ is one of the exceptions.

Does a Roth conversion raise my Medicare premiums?

It can. A conversion adds to your modified adjusted gross income, and Medicare sets IRMAA surcharges from your tax return from two years earlier. For a married couple filing jointly in 2026, one dollar over $218,000 costs two people $2,296.80 a year. See our IRMAA guide, which links the CMS tiers.

How were these numbers computed?

Every dollar figure is from the formula behind the free calculator: future value = converted amount × (1 + growth)^years; not converting leaves future value × (1 − rate at withdrawal); converting leaves future value × (1 − rate now); and paying the tax from outside savings adds the amount converted × rate now × rate at withdrawal × ((1 + growth)^years − 1). The examples use a $100,000 conversion at 60 with withdrawal at 75 and 7% a year growth, with flat tax rates. They leave out IRMAA, ACA subsidies, required minimum distributions, state tax and any gains already in the outside account, all of which can change a real decision. The IRS quotations are from the pages linked in each answer. This is educational information, not a forecast.

Runway content is educational only and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

Now model the full picture. See how a conversion interacts with your real accounts, IRMAA, and RMDs, year by year. Free to start, no credit card required.

Try the planner

About the author

Lei Huang is a former professor, turned founder and developer. He builds Runway, a DIY retirement income planner whose planning engine computes the figures in these posts. He is not a financial advisor.