Retirement spending

How much do you actually need to retire? A year-by-year answer, not a rule of thumb.

Ask "how much do I need to retire" and you'll usually get the same answer back: multiply your annual spending by 25, or take 4% of your savings as a safe withdrawal rate. Both versions of the same rule of thumb, both easy to remember, and both blind to almost everything that actually determines your real number: your Social Security timing, which accounts your money sits in, and how long your money actually needs to last.

Below is a real household, run through an actual retirement simulation, not an illustration, to show how far off the flat rule can land. (For the simpler idea of how many years your savings last, see what a retirement runway is.)

Quick answer. There's no single "how much do I need" number: the common 25x-expenses and 4%-rule shortcuts ignore your Social Security timing, which accounts your money sits in, and how long your plan actually needs to last. A real year-by-year simulation against your own accounts, not a flat multiple, is the only way to get a number that reflects your actual household: in the worked example below, the gap between the rule of thumb and the real answer is 68%.

The household

Pat, 62, and Alex, 60, are ready to retire now. Between them they have $1,200,000 saved, split across four accounts with very different tax treatment:

The household
Checking & savings (cash)$60,000
Joint taxable brokerage$350,000
Pat's traditional IRA$650,000
Pat's Roth IRA$140,000
Total$1,200,000

Both plan to claim Social Security at their full retirement age of 67: Pat's benefit will be $2,400/month, Alex's $1,800/month, so roughly $50,400/year combined once both are claiming. (Full retirement age and the early/delayed-claiming tradeoffs are set by the Social Security Administration: claiming as early as 62 permanently reduces the benefit, while delaying past full retirement age up to 70 permanently increases it.)

What does the flat rule say?

The 4% rule says: take 4% of $1,200,000, and that's your safe annual spending.

What does the flat rule say?
4% of $1,200,000$48,000/year

That's the entire calculation. It doesn't ask when Pat and Alex claim Social Security, doesn't know $650,000 of that total sits in a traditional IRA (taxed as ordinary income on withdrawal) versus $140,000 in a tax-free Roth (moving money from one to the other is its own decision worth running the numbers on, see our free Roth conversion calculator) and doesn't know whether their plan needs to last 20 years or 35.

What does a real simulation say?

Running Pat and Alex's actual accounts, ages, and Social Security timing through 2,000 simulated market paths (Runway's own Monte Carlo engine, targeting a 90% chance the money lasts through age 95) gives a very different number:

What does a real simulation say?
Real sustainable spending, 90% confidence$80,859/year
vs. the flat 4% rule$48,000/year
Difference+$32,859/year (68% more)

The flat rule wasn't cautious; it was simply missing information. At $48,000/year, this household's real simulated success rate comes back at 100%: they were on track to leave a large amount of money unspent, not because they were being careful, but because the rule never accounted for $50,400/year in future Social Security income at all.

The part a percentage can't give you: which account, and when

A safe withdrawal rate is still just one number. The more useful question is what actually happens each year. In year one, before either of them claims Social Security, Runway's withdrawal sequencing draws:

Year 1 (Pat 62, Alex 60)

Year 1 (Pat 62, Alex 60)
Checking & savings$60,000 (cash-first)
Joint taxable brokerage$27,086 (long-term capital gains)
Total withdrawn$87,086
Federal tax owed$0

Cash and long-term capital gains only, the traditional IRA stays untouched, so there's no ordinary income this year at all.

Year 6 (Pat 67, Alex 65, Social Security has started)

Year 6 (Pat 67, Alex 65, Social Security has started)
Total withdrawn from accounts$57,545

Once Pat's Social Security starts, the portfolio needs to cover a smaller share of spending, the withdrawal drops by about $29,000 in a single year, with no change in lifestyle at all.

That's the actual answer to "how much do I need": not one number, but a sequence of numbers, one per year, that changes as Social Security phases in, tax brackets fill up, and the plan ages, computed from this household's real accounts, not assumed from a multiple.

Once you have that number, the next question is whether it holds up under pressure: see how to stress-test a retirement plan against a market crash, history, and thousands of simulated futures.

These figures are illustrative: the result of one real simulation, for one example household, using today's tax rules and market assumptions. Your own real number depends on your own accounts, ages, and Social Security timing, which is exactly why a flat rule of thumb is a starting point, not an answer.
Runway content is educational only and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

See your own year-by-year number. Enter your real accounts and Social Security details and Runway will run the same simulation for you. Free to start, no credit card required.

Try the planner

Want your own number? The free retirement countdown calculator turns five numbers into the earliest month you could retire.

About the author

Lei Huang is a former professor, turned founder and developer. He builds Runway, a DIY retirement income planner whose planning engine computes the figures in these posts. He is not a financial advisor.